I think food items should have an "Always edible" checkbox, so that they can be eaten at anytime. This would be helpful to create items that behave like potions, golden apples or chorus fruits.
MCreator issue tracker has been migrated to GitHub.
Existing tickets have been migrated to GitHub. Please open new tickets on the GitHub tracker instead. If you do not have a GitHub account, all feature requests and bug reports from forums are still considered and checked by the maintainers.