What is a shapeless recipe?

Started by prettyinaccurate on

Topic category: Troubleshooting, bugs, and solutions

Active 7 years ago
Joined Jul 2018
Points:
699

User statistics:

  • Modifications: 0
  • Forum topics: 3
  • Wiki pages: 0
  • MCreator plugins: 0
  • Comments: 4
What is a shapeless recipe?

I'm making the recipes for tools and armor in my mod right now, and I'm not entirely sure what a shapeless recipe is? I tried looking at the forums, but all of it is saying how to make it, not what it is. I can't find any solution, anybody care to give a helping hand?

Active 4 years ago
Joined Jun 2016
Points:
3649

User statistics:

  • Modifications: 10
  • Forum topics: 39
  • Wiki pages: 0
  • MCreator plugins: 0
  • Comments: 5292
A shapeless recipe is a…
Tue, 07/17/2018 - 07:05

A shapeless recipe is a recipe with no shape. For example, you can craft a flint and steel in all the ways you want: flint on top and iron on bottom, flint on center and iron on left, etc. You just need to put an iron ingot and some flint in a crafting grid to make a flint and steel.

Sorry for bad English

Active 7 years ago
Joined Jul 2018
Points:
699

User statistics:

  • Modifications: 0
  • Forum topics: 3
  • Wiki pages: 0
  • MCreator plugins: 0
  • Comments: 4
Oh, okay, that makes sense…
Tue, 07/17/2018 - 23:15

Oh, okay, that makes sense. So I shouldn't put shapeless recipes for tools and armor, right? 

Active 4 years ago
Joined Jun 2016
Points:
3649

User statistics:

  • Modifications: 10
  • Forum topics: 39
  • Wiki pages: 0
  • MCreator plugins: 0
  • Comments: 5292
No, you shouldn't.   Can I…
Wed, 07/18/2018 - 06:24

No, you shouldn't.

 

Can I give you a tip on making recipes?

Mcreator recipes aren't "smart", so you sometimes need to make a lot of different recipes for a single item.

For a sword, for example, you can put the ingredients both in the center, at left and at right, so you need 3 recipes for it.

For a pickaxe just 1 recipe.

For an axe... 4 recipes. You need to make a recipe when the axe is at left, at right, when it's in the center facing left, in the center faving right...

For a shovel, like a sword, 3.

For an hoe, like an axe, 4.

For the armor, 2 for helmet, 2 for boots, 1 for chestplate and 1 for leggings.

 

Making recipes properly is a lot of work, and JEI will be filled with duplicate recipes, but if the player sees a bad recipe he will think that the mod is a bad mod even when it is a good one :(

Active 7 years ago
Joined Jul 2018
Points:
699

User statistics:

  • Modifications: 0
  • Forum topics: 3
  • Wiki pages: 0
  • MCreator plugins: 0
  • Comments: 4
Honestly, I don't think I'm…
Wed, 07/18/2018 - 07:36

Honestly, I don't think I'm going to do that lol. I'd much rather just stick to it being the center, cause not many people use the sides unless they're rushing or lazy.

Raol, you are right about…
Thu, 07/19/2018 - 09:51

Raol, you are right about the recipe "smartness". If you would mind, you can open a ticket and I will try to fix this in future updates.

Active 4 years ago
Joined Jun 2016
Points:
3649

User statistics:

  • Modifications: 10
  • Forum topics: 39
  • Wiki pages: 0
  • MCreator plugins: 0
  • Comments: 5292
Ok, I will :)
Thu, 07/19/2018 - 10:20

Ok, I will :)

Active 4 years ago
Joined Jun 2016
Points:
3649

User statistics:

  • Modifications: 10
  • Forum topics: 39
  • Wiki pages: 0
  • MCreator plugins: 0
  • Comments: 5292
That isn't a ticket. A…
Fri, 07/20/2018 - 10:09

That isn't a ticket. A ticket is an issue of the issue tracker  (https://mcreator.net/tracker), and not a forum topic. (However, your topic is a lot better than my ticket since it includes images XD)

Active 2 years ago
Joined Jul 2017
Points:
727

User statistics:

  • Modifications: 0
  • Forum topics: 5
  • Wiki pages: 0
  • MCreator plugins: 0
  • Comments: 10
Thanks!  
Sun, 02/24/2019 - 01:20

Thanks!

 

Active 3 years ago
Joined May 2018
Points:
1093

User statistics:

  • Modifications: 4
  • Forum topics: 17
  • Wiki pages: 0
  • MCreator plugins: 0
  • Comments: 564
The recipes Smartness has…
Sun, 02/24/2019 - 11:19

The recipes Smartness has been added! Cool

Active 6 months ago
Joined Jan 2016
Points:
949

User statistics:

  • Modifications: 0
  • Forum topics: 32
  • Wiki pages: 0
  • MCreator plugins: 0
  • Comments: 155
nice nice, good to know!!!
Fri, 08/14/2020 - 23:33

nice nice, good to know!!!